Worst trees! Says who?

Tue. Nov. 23, 2021

Click below to listen to my  2 min. Garden Bite radio show: Worst trees! Says Who?

 I discovered a list of trees that a site says are the WORST. After reading it I took issue with some of their “worst”. Frankly, one person’s “weed”, is another person’s “flower”. Take the dandelion.

That said, I’ll share some of their “worst” and my “not so”. There are a lot of reasons a tree isn’t fun to have around. They may be messy or weak and prone to damage… maybe they’re susceptible to disease or some where their roots love water and they shouldn’t be planted near septic tanks. THAT is a good reason not to plant an Aspen tree. Bummer, as I love them. Again, that’s ONLY a problem if you have a septic tank… 

Quaking Aspen

Now to the ones I’d risk a little messiness for. The Northern Catalpa tree!

Northern catalpa tree

Okay, so their leaves, once fallen aren’t very pretty, but in my opinion, those orchid-like flowers are WELL worth the fuss of ugly leaves and huge bean pods.

Northern catalpa pods
Northern catalpa tree flower cluster

One tree that’s similar is the Black Locust, which is invasive and not wanted! While native to parts of the U.S., that does not include the Upper Midwest. 

Black Locust flower cluster

The Horse Chestnut is on their ICK list because of it’s spiky seedpods. You can see more on MN Wildflowers too. 

Horse chestnut spiky pods

Okay, they’re pretty wicked BUT, the tree itself is fantastic for our northern climate.

Flowers and leaves of Horse chestnut

It provides plenty of shade, tolerates clay and alkaline soils and is also amenable to urban landscapes.

Horse chestnut tree

Honey Locust trees are another that many people do not like. Here’s a good reason…

Their small leaves aren’t much of an issue but the flattened seepods are a pain to rake up.

Honey locust seedpods
Honeylocust in Spring – a long ago picture from when I lived in Burnsville, MN. I don’t know what the cultivar was but it never had thorns.

However, there is a cultivar called ‘Sunburst’ that doesn’t have those seedpods and it’s very pretty.

‘Sunburst’ thornless
Thornless Honeylocust flowers